9:36 a.m. — Closing arguments to begin soon
It’s Thursday, Oct. 22 — the 18th day of trial for the man accused of killing UNC Chapel Hill student Faith Hedgepeth in September 2012. Miguel Salguero-Olivares is charged with murder, burglary, sexual offense and rape.
Closing arguments are expected to begin any minute. The courtroom is notably fuller than it has been any other day of trial, with scarcely a seat left.
In an unexpected move, defense attorneys told the court yesterday they would not put on any evidence in the case nor call any witnesses. 9th Street Reporter James Nguyen spoke with outside defense attorneys about this strategy.
9th Street Reporter Fiona Shuldiner shares five key takeaways from the trial so far.
–Sarah Krueger, Managing Editor
10:30 a.m. – ‘Forensic evidence in this case is screaming the truth’: Prosecutor stresses DNA evidence in closing argument and offers theory of motive
Closing arguments have begun, with the state of North Carolina making its case to the jury first.
Assistant District Attorney Garcia-Lamarca began her closing argument by describing the impact of Faith Hedgepeth’s death to her family.
“She was in college, she was making her way, and she was in her home,” she said. “Our homes are supposed to be our sanctuary.”

“For parents to lose a child and not know what happened, who did it, is unbearable,” she continued. “Now we know. We know what happened. Forensic evidence in this case is screaming the truth. We know what happened.”
Garcia-Lamarca stressed the DNA evidence the jury heard for days during expert witness testimony, which included a palm print matching Salguero-Olivares on a wine bottle at the scene.
“His semen is inside [Hedgepeth],” she said. “Her vagina, her rectum.”
Once Garcia-Lamarca described the charges brought against defendant Miguel Salguero-Olivares, she emphasized that the order of the alleged crimes – murder, rape, burglary and sexual offense – doesn’t matter.
“It was all part of the same, vicious attack,” she said. “Breaking into someone’s sanctuary in the middle of the night, and brutally murdering and sexually assaulting them. That’s the manner in which his killing was done.”
She stated that though the crimes are evident, the court may never know why they were committed.
“The problem is that the only person who knows why they commit a crime, potentially, if they even know, is the person who committed the crime. And they don’t have to tell us,” she said.
Garcia-Lamarca proposed a theory to the jury, though she said they do not have to believe this theory to find him guilty.
“It’s not a leap to suggest that he came up [to Karena Rosario and Faith Hedgepeth when they parked] and try to engage and [Hedgepeth] said ‘what are you stupid can’t you see, she is sick, go away,’” she said. “Faith shut him down. She embarrassed him. When he saw Karena leave, he knew Faith was there alone. He was angry. He was acting out of rage. He did everything he could to make himself feel powerful and important.”
Before the assistant district attorney finished her closing argument, she stressed to the jury the one question she says they need to answer while deliberating: “Do you believe the forensic evidence in this case?”
“Tell [Salguero-Olivares]. Stop him. Tell him what he already knows. He has known for 14 years. You’re the conscience of this community. You decide on behalf of Durham and North Carolina,” she said.
The court is on a short recess until 10:45 a.m., when prosecutors will finish their closing arguments before defense attorneys present theirs.
–JAMES NGUYEN
12:12 p.m. ‘Don’t get conspiratorial’: In second part of closing argument, special prosecutor attempts to anticipate defense attorneys’ upcoming arguments
The court returned from a short recess and special prosecutor Lisa Coltrain delivered the second portion of the state’s closing arguments.
Coltrain told the jury that, because defense attorneys will get the final word, her aim is to anticipate arguments they will make and respond to them. Coltrain said she suspects the defense will use “red herrings,” or information that would seek to mislead people away from the main points, and distract the jury from the trial’s evidence.

“What I don’t want you to do is get sucked into nonsense. Because that’s just noise,” she said. “The evidence is louder than the noise.”
Coltrain criticized defense attorneys for not calling witnesses or putting on any evidence, despite telling jurors during opening statements that they would.
“They told you you’re going to see photos of the evidence technicians not wearing gloves. Did y’all see that?… Nope,” she said. “He told you he was going to put on evidence. [He] didn’t. Because it’s noise.”
She sought to again establish the credibility of Hedgepeth’s roommate, Karena Rosario, who she anticipated the defense would try to implicate.
Coltrain stated anything in this case to do with Rosario “is just noise” aimed at being a distraction, and cannot erase that Salguero-Olivares DNA and prints were at the crime scene.
“Karena’s not on trial. Karena is a victim of this circumstance,” she said. “Karena is a distraction that makes no sense… It is a distraction because whatever it is doesn’t take [Salguero-Olivares’] sperm out of Faith’s body.” “How could [Rosario] pull out Faith’s tampon without getting her own DNA on it but somehow getting a male’s DNA on it?”
Coltrain discussed a red stain on the bathroom door frame, seen in a photo displayed during trial. Defense attorneys have repeatedly stressed that this stain was not tested for DNA, and highlighted that, by her own account, Rosario was in the bathroom for much of the early morning.
Coltrain, however, said the lack of testing on that is inconsequential.
“What do we think this would tell us?” she asked. “What does this tell us? Absolutely nothing.”
Coltrain told the jury she also anticipates the defense will claim the law enforcement investigation was inadequate, as he has done during trial. Coltrain stressed there is no perfect investigation, and this is no exception. Despite any investigative shortcoming, she said the DNA is enough.
“The defendant’s DNA was all over that crime scene. It had no business of being [there],” she said. “He left his DNA like confetti all over that room.”
She mentioned the DNA found on Hedgepeth’s boxer shorts and white take-out bag, along with a palm print matching Salguero-Olivares on a wine bottle at the scene.
“It does not negate this murder weapon with his DNA on it,” she said, referring to a Bacardi rum bottle. “No matter what kind of mistakes were made or things that were missed, it doesn’t erase the palm print. It doesn’t somehow lift the DNA out of Faith. That evidence still exists.”
As Coltrain began to conclude the state’s closing argument, she reminded the jury that the evidence, particularly the forensic and DNA evidence, should be the foundation for their verdict.
“This is not a game where we try to distort things to make things fit,” she said. “This is real life. And this is reason and common sense. We’re not in the business of conspiracies… The actual evidence screams at you.”

Several jurors were wiping away tears as Coltrain mentioned Hedgepeth’s family members, who have been in the courtroom every day of the trial.
“This is not crime-time entertainment for her family…[Salguero-Olivares] beat her until her skull cracked like an egg. That girl didn’t have a chance,” said Coltrain, as people in the courtroom were hugging and consoling each other.
“The evidence is loud, it is clear, it is screaming at you that this defendant did this,” Coltrain said, as she walked across the courtroom to stand right in front of the defendant. “The guilt has been here since Sept. 7 and it remains here now…Put the guilt where it belongs. Find him guilty.
The court is on lunch break until 1:15 p.m., when the defense will begin its arguments.
–JAMES NGUYEN
3:00 p.m. In closing arguments, defense reiterates concerns about Hedgepeth’s roommate, quality of investigation; says state hasn’t met burden of proof
Closing arguments for the defense, delivered by attorneys James Rainsford and Jason Murphy, lasted about an hour.
They claimed the state has not met its burden of proof that the crimes were committed by Salguero-Olivares.
“We are not here to prove anything…it’s up to the state to rule these things out, to close these things down,” Rainsford said.
Murphy emphasized that while prosecutors believe Salguero-Olivares was at a cookout at Hedgepeth’s apartment complex the night of her murder, they did not provide definitive evidence that he was there.
Similarly, the defense argued that despite Salguero-Olivares’ DNA being found in Hedgepeth’s vagina and rectum, this does not prove a crime was committed. Murphy suggested that intercourse could have been consensual.
“You can find DNA up to five days after intercourse, even more than that,” he said.
As they have done throughout trial, defense attorneys sought to cast doubt on Karena Rosario, Hedgepeth’s roommate. They repeated arguments surrounding the blood on Karena’s finger, questioning her claim of not remembering telling Jordan McCrary about having had blood on her finger.
“Memory, something being forgotten, is something inherently important that the state has asked you to accept,” Murphy said.
Rainsford also called into question the diligence of the whole investigation, highlighting a mis-step Friday when an SBI agent showed a handwritten image found on Salguero-Olivares’ computer, asking the jury to compare the handwriting to a note found at the crime scene. Monday, the SBI agent said he had learned over the weekend the image was actually a viral meme.
Rainsford suggested that demonstrated poor and insufficient investigatory diligence that may have affected other evidence, too.
“Somebody has lost their life and that will not change,” Rainsford told the jury. “But to say that because of that we can gloss over things, that’s not the law. That’s not fair.”
The jury has been instructed to separate their personal feelings toward the case from the clear criterion needed to be fulfilled in order to prove guilt.
“Maybe you like parts of the state’s case, but you need a little bit more…that’s the state’s burden,” Rainsford said.
“They have not proved their case,” he continued. “Hold them to their burden. He is not guilty.”
–GEMMA TUTTON
Photo at top: Miguel Salguero-Olivares is charged with murder, rape, burglary and sexual offense. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges. Pool photo
9th Street Journal Staff


