Press "Enter" to skip to content

With no verdict yet, longtime defense attorney reflects on jury deliberations in Hedgepeth trial

As we head toward the weekend with jurors still deliberating in the Faith Hedgepeth trial, a criminal defense attorney who is not related to the case shared insight into when we might be able to expect a verdict from the jury. 

“It really depends on the foreperson, and how they’re leading deliberations,” said Daniel Meier, a longtime Durham defense attorney. “When you’re talking about a case this serious…they tend to take it a lot more deliberately.” 

Miguel Salguero-Olivares is accused of killing Hedgepeth, a UNC student, on Sept. 7, 2012 in her off-campus apartment. He is charged with murder, rape, burglary and sexual offense. If convicted of first-degree murder, he faces a mandatory sentence of life in prison. The Durham County District Attorney’s Office previously announced it was not seeking the death penalty in this case. 

The jury began deliberating Thursday around 3:30 p.m. Meier said the upcoming weekend could motivate jurors to reach a decision more quickly. 

“Sometimes you tend to see things rush a little quicker on a Friday than you would see on a Thursday,” he said. 

Jurors have been in the courtroom since Sept. 28, when jury selection began. The jury selection process lasted seven-and-a-half days. Then, over the course of nine days of testimony, jurors heard from 23 witnesses, and saw dense scientific evidence as well as graphic photos from the crime scene. The emotional consequences of a jury’s role can weigh heavily on jurors, as the impact of their decision means someone’s life is taken away, vindicated, or still left asking for restitution from beyond the grave. 

“It’s a decision that is one way or the other going to completely destroy one side’s life,” Meier said. “Because they’re either going to say to one side, yeah your daughter’s killer is still out there, or they’re going to say to the other side, your loved one is a killer and he’s going to die in prison and you’ll never be able to hug them again.”

The prosecution’s argument relied heavily on dense DNA evidence. Forensic analysis in particular could offer a substantial delay in jury deliberations, according to Meier. 

“Those reports are long…they are worded weird, there’s just a lot of paperwork to go through methodically, one by one,” he said. 

To reach a verdict, the 12-person jury must agree. However, they can find Salguero-Olivares guilty of some of the charges and not guilty of others, in what is known as a split verdict. Meier noted that, if the jury agrees Salguero-Olivares is guilty of first-degree murder, their decisions on the other charges are less consequential, as a first-degree murder conviction has a mandatory sentence of life in prison. 

When the defense “is arguing the reasonable doubt, one of the things juries have to overcome is if they think [he] did it…if they acknowledge a reasonable doubt, they’re supposed to find not guilty,” Meier said.  

Meier said this pillar of the court is often misunderstood, and is a key factor affecting the jury’s deliberation time and subsequent decision. 

“Sometimes it’s hard for people to come to grips with, well, I think someone did it, but I acknowledge I might not be right, so I’m going to go not guilty,” he said. 

This is where jurors may decide to compromise. 

“You have some people who say, ‘I want first-degree murder.’ Other people say, ‘I want not guilty’ or ‘I want manslaughter.’ Then they [ask], could we all agree on 2nd degree or something like that,” Meier said. 

Meier said anytime jurors do not reach a verdict immediately, defense attorneys take that as a good sign. He reflected on his mentality as a defense attorney when jurors spend time deliberating.

“If the defense can keep him out at least a half hour to 45 minutes, we’ve got them thinking,” he said. “I’ve had them go as long as three-and-a-half, four days. On a murder, the quickest I’ve had is about five hours.” 

Meier speculated the jury could reach a decision this afternoon. While the clock ticks on, bystanders in the Durham County Court are watching the small side door leading to the jury’s conference room, waiting for whichever sign leads to their dismissal for the day, or an eternally different future. 

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes. | Powered by Sanford WordPress