Press "Enter" to skip to content

Defense opts not to call any witnesses in Hedgepeth trial – how common is that?

Over the course of nine days, prosecutors in the Faith Hedgepeth trial called 23 witnesses to testify. But when it was defense attorneys’ turn to call witnesses to the stand Wednesday, they revealed they would call none, despite earlier references to their plans to put on evidence.

Defendant Miguel Salguero-Olivares also decided not to take the stand. While the prosecution was clearly surprised by the defense’s approach, outside defense lawyers were not. 

Daniel Meier, a longtime Durham defense attorney, told The 9th Street Journal that, in the majority of cases, the defense decides not to call any witnesses. 

“They try to avoid it frankly,” he said. “It’s more unusual for the defense to put on witnesses than it is for them to not.”

When asked about why the defense often avoids calling witnesses, Meier mentioned the importance of getting the last word with the jury. When defense attorneys present evidence, that permits prosecutors to deliver the final remarks. 

“If you put on evidence, you lose [the] last [closing argument],” he said. “Do [witnesses] add anything and do they risk the chance of getting tripped up on cross-examination? The state has the burden of proof. They have to prove their case.”

Scott Holmes, a defense attorney and senior clinical professor at the North Carolina Central University School of Law, shared similar sentiments. 

“It’s very common for criminal defense lawyers to not call witnesses in a trial, for a variety of reasons,” he said.

A defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty. In the Hedgepeth murder trial, defense attorney James Rainsford told the court he believed the state did not meet its burden of proof. Holmes said that is a common reason why defense attorneys sometimes opt not to put on evidence, and instead may point out what they perceive to be holes in the state’s argument.

“Sometimes, defense attorneys believe that there are so many gaps that it’s better to just argue that the state hasn’t met its burden and didn’t investigate the case well, or haven’t connected the defendant beyond a reasonable doubt to the crime,” Holmes said.

Similarly, Holmes said it is not unusual for a defendant to decide not to testify.

“One of the most common reasons is, very often, the criminal defendant has a prior criminal history,” he said. “If they were to testify, they would have to admit to previous criminal convictions.” 

Further, a defendant may self-incriminate without notice. 

“Sometimes, the client isn’t a good witness,” he said. “There may be aspects of what he’s going to say that aren’t believable or admit to things that are incriminating, that aren’t necessarily the crime, that might prejudice him with the jury.”

In the eyes of the law, there are certain strategies the prosecution and defense can use to win their case with a jury. Holmes and Meier both highlighted the importance of jury selection, and how defense lawyers constantly stress the same messages with each potential juror on what the defendant is entitled to do.

“You stress repeatedly that the court is going to let you know the defendant doesn’t have to testify and you can’t hold that against them if they don’t,” Meier said.

Thursday morning, attorneys from both sides will deliver closing arguments in the case. Then, the jury will begin deliberating. All 12 jurors must come to a unanimous agreement, or the trial proceeds to a mistrial and no conviction is presented.

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes. | Powered by Sanford WordPress