Press "Enter" to skip to content

Posts published by “Bill McCarthy”

How ‘Ms. Xenia’ keeps the community together at Forest View Elementary

In a back hallway at Forest View Elementary School, a small boy sits at a desk outside the assistant principal’s office, his shoulders slumped under a gray hoodie and his feet dangling above the floor.

Xenia Carcamo, a school custodian, stops and whispers something in his ear. He smiles.

This is part of her magic, a sign of how she connects with the students at Forest View. She says this spot is where teachers send students who are having difficulty in class.

“Some students have behavior problems, and I always try to go closer to them,” she says. “Maybe in their family, they don’t have attention, or they don’t have love. And maybe they want to find that in the school, so I don’t have a problem giving it to them.”

In her 13 years at Forest View, Carcamo has become a vital part of the community, playing a role much larger than her title might suggest. She knows almost all of the students by name, and they refer to her affectionately as “Ms. Xenia.”

By state standards, Forest View is an average school, having received a “C” for performance in 2017-18. But the grades don’t tell the full story.

There are 40 different countries represented among the school’s more than 750 students. The student body is 36 percent Hispanic, 30 percent white, 21 percent black and 7 percent Asian.

Forest View is a melting pot of cultures. Now the school’s lead custodian, Carcamo knits the diverse community together as a translator, as an inspiration, and as a friend to everyone.

Carcamo is tall, with a round face and a big smile that makes her eyes squint. She says she came to the United States from El Salvador in 1997 and worked at a sunglasses company in New York for nine years.

Her move was complicated by some unexpected twists, which she recalls with tears in her eyes. First she separated from her husband. Then her daughter, 6 years old at the time, developed brain cancer. She died seven years later.

Looking for a fresh start, Carcamo moved her two other children once more, this time to North Carolina. She says she hoped to get a job with the state government, but her difficulty speaking English got in the way. Instead, she sent a job-seeking note to Forest View with her son, who was a student. Later that same day, she went in for her first interview.

Since her hiring, Carcamo has bounced between full-time and part-time jobs as a custodian and also as a member of the cafeteria staff. She says she takes pride in her work, and that she feels protective of the school’s students, especially after losing a child of her own.

“If they need something, I’m always there,” she says.

She says the children — especially the native Spanish speakers — go to her when they’re sad or distressed. Teachers do the same when they need help getting through to their students.

“Sometimes the teachers come to me and say, ‘Xenia, can you help with this? Can you ask him why he’s sad or why he’s crying?” she says.

On one occasion, she says a boy named Justin asked her for a second breakfast during her shift in the cafeteria. Speaking in Spanish, she asked why he needed a second helping. He said his mother hadn’t been feeding him properly at home.

“I’m always keeping my eyes on them,” Carcamo says of students like Justin. “In some countries, you can see or you have to live with what I call the hungry face. If you never see the hungry face, you can’t understand how these kids feel.”

Her workday starts at 10 a.m., but she says she regularly arrives at 8:30 a.m. and stays late into the evening.

“My goal is to have everything ready so they can come into a safe place, a clean place,” she says. “So if I have to work extra hours, I don’t care nothing about it.”

Carcamo and Ronnie Winston, assistant principal of Forest View Elementary School. (Photo: Katie Nelson).

Forest View’s students, teachers and administrators love her dedication. “She always puts the students first and she takes pride in her work,” says assistant principal Ronnie Winston, who has known and supported her since her move to North Carolina.

Carcamo says she has a special place in her heart for children, which makes it easier for her to go the extra mile. But just as she supports Forest View’s students, she’s also become a go-to resource for Hispanic candidates applying for custodial positions in Durham.

She says she’s recruited several people to positions in Durham public schools, including multiple members of Forest View’s six-person custodial staff. “The first thing that I always say is, if you can help somebody go to the next step, why not?” she says.

Winston says Carcamo’s recruiting has been helpful, and that he knows any candidate she’s recommended will work hard to keep the school clean.

“If Xenia says so, I don’t question it,” he says. “I know they’re going to do a good job.”

Durham’s custodial jobs have been more attractive since the district recently switched from an outside contractor to an in-house model, Carcamo says. Now that custodians work directly for the district, they get better benefits, such as insurance and the ability to take more sick days.

That’s important, she says, because it’s easy for custodians to find themselves being taken for granted.

“Sometimes, some people make you feel like, ‘Oh, she’s custodian, I can throw away this one here and they get paid to clean,’” she says. “Some people, they are like that. But people are people and you need to respect everybody.”

Students at Forest View expressed their gratitude for the custodians on staff with a key-shaped poster. (Photo: Katie Nelson).

But at Forest View, Carcamo feels like she’s earned everybody’s respect. She adores her role, and she says she’s never considered leaving, even as other opportunities have popped up.

“I always say this is my family,” she says.

Lakewood and Mangum: Comparing Durham’s worst and best performing schools

Lakewood Elementary School, nestled in a neighborhood adjacent to Duke Forest, has a relatively new principal. James Hopkins has been principal for a little more than a year.

So does Mangum Elementary, the northernmost K-5 school in the county. Gwendolyn Dorman took over in April.

But the two schools are miles apart, not just geographically, but also in test scores.

By state standards, Mangum is the highest-performing elementary school in Durham County. In 2017-18, it exceeded growth status and received an “A” for school performance. But Lakewood is one of the district’s lowest performers, having received an “F” last year.

Related story: How reliable are the state’s performance grades?

In 2017, Lakewood was one of the final six schools considered for state takeover by the North Carolina Innovative School District, an intervention program for low-performing schools.

It was ultimately dropped from the state’s final list. Now, with a year under his belt, Hopkins said his school could be trending up. He’s hired five new teachers and is excited for the future.

Meanwhile, Dorman hopes to keep Mangum at the top. But the pressure she feels is different.

“The lower-performing schools have a lot of stress coming down from the top, where any stress that we have in our building is created by us ourselves,” she said.

Lakewood Elementary

Lakewood has about 470 students and is tucked in a neighborhood of homes and apartment complexes near Duke Forest. But many wealthy families in that area have sent their children to private schools.

Lakewood Elementary School received an “F” for school performance in 2017-18. (Photo: Bill McCarthy)

According to data compiled by ProPublica in 2017, the student body is about 54 percent Hispanic and 37 percent are black, with 100 percent of students receiving free or reduced-price lunches. That makes it one of the state’s poorest and most diverse schools.

The school has long been among the district’s lowest performers, having also received an “F” in 2016-17. In 2017, it was one of two Durham public schools assigned to the state’s Restart program, an experimental effort which gives struggling schools charter-like flexibilities.

That means Hopkins has freedom to use the school’s money however he sees fit. While other principals are hamstrung by specific teaching allotments, Lakewood gets more of a lump sum.

“It has been a huge blessing,” Hopkins said.

One benefit has been the ability to control class sizes. If not for the Restart program, Lakewood would have had to put teachers in trailers to keep class sizes below the state cap, Hopkins said.

“All of my teachers are in the building this year because we don’t have to subscribe to the class size limits,” he said.

The flexibility has also helped Hopkins make accommodations for Lakewood’s large Hispanic population. He’s been working to purchase translation headphones so he can communicate more easily with Spanish-speaking parents.

“I’m a rhythm speaker,” he said. “I hate having to stop and give you the microphone to interpret to Spanish. So we would not have been able to do that if we were not a Restart school.”

Since taking over, Hopkins and his staff have set their sights on bumping proficiency to 50 percent, up from the 37 percent that earned an “F” score in 2017-18. In addition the five new teachers, Hopkins said he hired a specially-trained teacher to work with struggling students.

“This year, with the team that I brought on board and the support that the district has provided us, there is no doubt that we are going to meet growth and we stand a very, very good chance of exceeding growth,” Hopkins said. “But there’s also no doubt in my mind, and I can almost guarantee this, that we will not be an ‘F’ school next year. We’ll be ‘D’ or a ‘C.’”

Hopkins said he’s optimistic that others in the area will notice the changes he’s put in place.

“Parents are coming back to Lakewood from charter schools and from private schools,” he said. “My goal is for Lakewood to reflect the demographics of its community, and right now it doesn’t. The goal is obviously to make sure that our school looks like our community, but we’re on our way there.”

Mangum Elementary

Mangum Elementary School received an “A” for school performance in 2017-18. (Photo: Katie Nelson)

Mangum is the northernmost elementary school in Durham County, with about 320 students from the community of Bahama and the surrounding area. The campus is rural, its main entrance tucked behind a giant oak tree and its water flowing from a well out back.

The school’s student body is about 82 percent white, according to ProPublica, and only 23 percent get free or reduced-priced lunches. It’s not a magnet school, but it does have several students transfer in from neighboring communities each year, Dorman said.

Mangum is also one of few Durham public schools that doesn’t receive Title I funding — money given to schools with high numbers of children from low-income families — so Dorman said it leans on community partnerships and its parent-teacher organization for support.

Parent volunteers are always willing to help, she explained. Some parents like to come in before school to make copies of worksheets so teachers don’t have to. Others build stage decorations for the school play.

Dorman said the teachers are just as invested, as well.

Gwendolyn Dorman took over as principal of Mangum Elementary School in April. (Photo: Katie Nelson)

“We’re a community-based school,” she said. “Our teachers who teach here went to school here. They live in Bahama. Their children went here.”

The music teacher runs a music club for fifth grade students, for example, and the physical education teacher puts on a run-walk club on Tuesday and Thursday mornings for students and community members.

“Parents, grandparents, all kinds of people are out there on the track in the morning,” Dorman said.

“One thing the teachers do really well here is they provide students with a wide range of opportunities and they build background knowledge in a lot of different areas that they might not experience outside of school,” added assistant principal Tyler Steketee.

Inside the classroom, teachers balance preparation for the state’s year-end exams with engaging lesson plans. Dorman said Mangum’s is distinct from other elementary schools because it treats the fourth and fifth grades like middle school.

“We departmentalize our fourth and fifth grades,” Dorman said. “So if you’re a fourth-grade teacher, your job might be to teach math. You have three different classes that come to you for fourth-grade math.”

Other teachers specialize in English language acquisition and STEM, she said.

Dorman said departmentalization — a practice the school first tried out four years ago — lets teachers specialize in the subjects they’re most passionate about. It also gives them the chance to share the tactics and teaching styles that work for specific students.

For students, the practice limits the chance of having to spend all day with a teacher they don’t like.

“You get to go and you have to focus for an hour and a half, and then you get to change classes and go on to your next subject, Dorman said. “It very much prepares you for middle school.”

How reliable are the state’s performance grades?

North Carolina has been rating school performance on an A-through-F scale since 2013-14, when the Republican-led state legislature started the letter-grading system.

Schools are assessed on a 100-point scale, with 80 percent of the grade coming from the percent of students who pass exams and the other 20 percent factoring in year-to-year growth.

Supporters of the system say letter grades provide a simple way for parents, educators and community members to assess how various schools are doing. But critics say that the system tends to stigmatize schools in high poverty areas.

Lakewood Elementary Principal James Hopkins said the state standards are a valuable guide for assessing teachers, but the grading formula is “backwards” because it “can undermine efforts made in areas in North Carolina that have historically struggled to achieve proficiency, but have not struggled to meet growth.”

I think that the current model, the formula, does not help reflect what schools are doing,” he said. “I understand why the state wants to have grades, but I think the formula is flawed and it gives a very negative perception for schools like Lakewood.”

Related story: Lakewood and Mangum: Comparing Durham’s worst and best performing schools

Even as Lakewood received an “F” grade for 2017-18, it met its growth expectation, and Hopkins said a model that gives more weight to a school’s growth status would better reflect the learning happening in more disadvantaged classrooms.

“The way that its reflected in the paper is that Lakewood is a failing school,” he said. “To say that we are an F school I think deflates any additional efforts that we have made in trying to address some of our learning gaps with our students.”

Gwendolyn Dorman, principal of Mangum Elementary School,  agreed that test scores can be misleading, but said Magnum would score well even if the formula were flipped. “We’re definitely getting the growth that we need,” she said.

For better or worse, schools have to work with the system they’re handed, she said.

“There’s lots of research on whether tests are culturally biased,” she said. “And whether they are or aren’t, unfortunately we have to teach (students) for the test.”

At Forest View Elementary, a teacher who has seen it all but isn’t ready to retire

She’s still asking her question when the first hand shoots up. Within seconds, every student at the table has a hand in the air.

Sylvia Perry, 59, is used to this excitement from her students. She raises her eyebrows and nods to a girl in pink. The girl starts to reply, her voice a soft murmur. Then, questioning herself, she pauses.

Perry leans into the table, stretches her arm across it and gently pokes the girl’s forehead with a pencil. “I know you know this in that smart, pretty head of yours,” she says.

Speaking up this time, the girl says she lives with her parents and one sister, which is different from the many Pilgrims who formed larger families during the colonial period. Perry flashes a smile and tells her that’s a good answer.

The assignment this Monday morning is simple. The handful of students still in the classroom — those who haven’t been pulled for English as a Second Language tutoring or another related program — are instructed to read an original colonial text and look for ways the Pilgrims’ lives were like or unlike their own.

Perry, who’s been teaching for 38 years, says colonial lessons are always a favorite for the fifth-graders at Forest View Elementary School, a K-5 school south of Duke Forest on Mount Sinai Road. Many of them don’t know how the United States got started.

The student body is 36 percent Hispanic, 30 percent white, 21 percent black and 7 percent Asian, according to school statistics. Perry says her classroom last year represented 18 different countries.

“We are a very diverse school,” says Linda Foreman, an administrative specialist. “There is no racial or ethnic majority.”

By state standards, Forest View is an average school. In 2017-18, it met growth status and received a “C” for school performance. But the grades don’t tell the full story. The school is a melting pot of cultures with a distinctly large refugee population. It’s a unique spot with a young teaching staff.

Perry, who came out of retirement to join the staff six years ago, is the elder of the group — the veteran social studies teacher who has seen it all.


Perry speaks in a gentle tone and a southern accent that gives away her Memphis, Tennessee, upbringing. She’s petite, with glasses and blonde hair cut just short of her shoulders, but even the tallest children in her classroom seem to look up to her.

There’s 42 of them in total — two groups of 21 — and Perry says she knows them well by now. On a board on the wall, there’s a class contract she’s had her students create every year. It says teachers and students are expected to treat each other maturely, lovingly and patiently.

Perry was born into education, her mother an American history teacher and her father a professor of philosophy, but she found her own way into the profession when a college work study placed her in a teaching role for the first time.

By the time she arrived in Durham, she had earned a degree in special education and a masters in elementary education and spent 32 years teaching the first, second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth and eighth grades in Tennessee. “I’ve taught in almost every concept,” she says.

Over the years, she has learned what works in the classroom. As her students return to her room after lunch, she greets each of them with a fist-bump-turned-peace-sign, a years-old move she calls the “Perry pound.” Even some of her first students, who have stayed in touch through Facebook, have told her they remember this move.

For the most part, she sticks to the basics. “My whole thing is kind,” she says. “I tell [my students] when they show up everyday that it’s a great day to be kind.”

She doesn’t fight the small battles, either. When students forget to return a pencil, she doesn’t mind. When a child gets upset with her, she connects that child to a counselor so he or she can air frustrations in private. But even that doesn’t happen often, she says.

“As long as you don’t lie to me and as long as you’re not mean-spirited, we’re going to get along fine,” she says.

Since coming to Forest View, Perry has taught exclusively fifth-graders. “This is kind of the year of organization before they go off and switch classes,” she says. Middle school is a big leap for some children, so she focuses on building good reading and working habits.

At one point during an individual reading assignment, a small boy in a thick Navy sweatshirt and jean shorts looks up from his reading. His hands tucked into his sleeves and his body slouched, he is evidently distracted.

Perry leans over his shoulder, her hands crossed behind her back. “I think a good strategy would be to go chapter by chapter and try to take two minutes for each one,” she says.

Later, another student raises his hand. “Do I have to read this part?” he asks, pointing to a line in his book.

“Yes, you always want to read the captions because that’s an important text feature.”

Perry worries that reading is becoming “a dying art,” so she reads out loud to her students at least once each day. In a typical year, her curriculum covers American history from the colonial period through the Civil Rights movement.

“I always do a huge Civil Rights unit,” she says.


Perry can remember exactly where she was in Memphis when, as a fifth-grader, she learned that the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. had been assassinated.

“Civil rights was always a part of my life,” she says. “My father was one of the people who headed up the Sanitation Strike in Memphis. There were people in our basement making signs, and our house got egged all the time.”

That historical footing is important, she says, because so many of her students, including many African-American children, are getting their first exposure to American history from her.

“So many kids who, if they don’t have that heritage, or if the heritage is painful and they don’t talk about it — it amazes me how little is known about that struggle, when for people like me, that’s a huge part of my life,” she says. “I think sometimes they don’t realize their strong heritage and what was overcome, and the fact that it really wasn’t that long ago.”

“If they don’t know their history, it might repeat, and I don’t want that because I tend to believe that each generation should make it better.”

Perry doesn’t soften the horrors of slavery, either. Every year, she assigns readings from slave diaries and takes her students to the International Civil Rights Center and Museum in Greensboro. “I learned the whitewashed history,” she says, but her students get the full picture.

“Now we study the American revolution, but we read a book that talks about how the Patriots weren’t so nice to their Tory neighbors,” she says. “‘Nothing is all good and all bad,’ I tell them. Nobody is all right or all wrong, and there all some sadder things about our country.”

Sometimes, this history is hard to make sense of, especially for her refugee students who are still new to the country. But she tries to learn about their home cultures too so she can compare and contrast. The fact that some students may struggle is no reason to lower the bar, she says.

“I hold the bar high even for the kids that come from disadvantaged backgrounds,” she says. “When we lower the bar, what we’re telling them is, ‘You can’t get there.’ I always tell them that I’ll scaffold, I’ll build, I’ll put in supports and we’ll get you there, but we won’t lower the bar.”


Others at Forest View have taken a liking to Perry’s progressive lesson plans and age-old tactics. Administrators don’t shy away from giving her tough assignments. “She’s a veteran who can roll with the punches,” says Forest View Principal Neil Clay.

“The diversity of this building is a unique experience for almost everyone, and of course what she brings … is experience,” adds Foreman, the school’s administrative specialist. “She’s just seen so much and been through so much. She’s a really good role model for younger teachers.”

Perry knows this. She says it’s part of what made her jump back into education in the first place.

“I’m kind of like a mother to the teachers,” she says. “I really kind of want to use all my expertise now, because I see so many young teachers who seem overwhelmed when they come in.”

“Clearly I could retire, and I don’t, because I like it.”

Durham public schools to close Thursday for Hurricane Michael

Durham public schools will close Thursday in anticipation of heavy rains from Hurricane Michael, school officials announced today.

“Due to the probability of travel conditions becoming unsafe during the school day due to Hurricane Michael, Durham Public Schools will be CLOSED to students and staff on Thursday, Oct. 11,” the district said in a statement.

All athletic events and extracurricular activities scheduled for Thursday have also been canceled.

The decision follows Superintendent Pascal Mubenga’s apology to the community for holding classes during Hurricane Florence, when torrential rains and a tornado warning turned a Monday morning commute into mayhem for parents, teachers and staff.

New foundation asks Durham residents to raise money for public schools

The state isn’t providing enough money for schools, so business and community leaders say it’s time for the community to pitch in.

They have started a foundation to raise money to support the public schools.

The new Durham Public Schools Foundation, which launched during August’s convocation, lets residents send tax-deductible donations to support the school system. Foundation leaders say the money could help schools pay for expenses the state’s funds cannot cover, such as student field trips or professional development for teachers.

The concept may seem strange, but the foundation puts Durham in line with other urban districts in the state that have set up similar nonprofits, including Wake, Chapel Hill-Carrboro and Greensboro. Steve Unruhe, vice chair of the Durham board of education and one of the foundation’s first donors, said Durham used to have a foundation but got rid of it a decade ago after it “went south.”

Since then, the idea has regained popularity among district residents. “There’s been a lot of interest in supporting the school system and a lot of groups that support the school system in various ways,” Unruhe said. “But we’ve been really lacking a systematic approach to that and that’s what the foundation can give us.”

In its first month, the new foundation raised approximately $125,000 from more than 90 donors, said board member Magan Gonzales-Smith. Most contributions have been individual donations of less than $1,000, with the largest total to date coming from the Durham public schools system, according to the foundation’s “Supporters” page.

Gonzales-Smith explained that the school system made a one-time contribution of $70,000 in “early start-up funds” to help launch the foundation and that the group pledged to eventually invest more than $70,000 back into the school system.

“It is not uncommon that school districts provide funds at times to their local education foundation but ultimately the foundation contributes far more back to district schools,” she said.

She said foundation leaders are in conversation with several corporate donors who plan to give even more than the school system did. “We feel like it’s been very successful and we’re in a really good starting point,” she said.

But while the money is already rolling in, ideas on how to spend it are not quite as developed.

“It’s all going to depend on what we hear back from our communities,” Gonzales-Smith said. “It’s going to take us time to really get out there and hear what kinds of work is going to be most supportive to them. We just can’t say exactly what it is yet.”

Broadly speaking, the foundation is meant to boost enrollment and improve the education for students already there. As a result, much of the money will likely go toward developing Durham’s teachers, Unruhe said.

“There’s the simple and very concrete efforts to help teachers, so ways to have grants that teachers can apply for, support for teachers to design their own professional development, special projects, that kind of thing,” he said.

“One of the projects will certainly be to support teachers with their creative classroom ideas,” added Mayor Steve Schewel, an adviser to the foundation.

The money will also help pay for new student experiences, Gonzales-Smith said. “If a middle school in Durham wants to take their eighth-grade class to D.C. to see the Smithsonian and African-American History Museum, we would fund trips like that.”

Parents can expect to benefit from the money, as well. According to a fundraising solicitation, small donations between $25 and $1,000 could help provide translators or other language assistance for parents visiting their child’s school.

A foundation fundraising card outlines donor levels and says what each donation could fund (Courtesy: Magan Gonzales-Smith)

But the foundation’s biggest impact may be helping the school system tell its story, Unruhe said. “It’s very difficult to get the story of what’s happening in schools out to the community. We badly need our communities to know what the public schools are doing.”

“The role of the foundation is to help accelerate the great work that’s already happening,” Gonzales-Smith added.

The foundation will not overlap with service-oriented education nonprofits already in Durham, however, and it will not use its money to purchase school supplies or offer tutoring services. “That’s the job of the taxpayers directly,” Unruhe said. “This is a broader scale.”

Local education foundations have been around since the 1980s, explained Robin Callahan, executive director of the National School Foundation Association. Approximately 4,000 of the nation’s 12,000 public school districts now have foundations, she said.

“Education foundations are the fastest-growing nonprofit sector,” Callahan said. “Every week almost, I talk to a new community that is working on starting a new education foundation.”

The Durham group will be led by a 20-person board of directors comprised of parents, educators, government officials and business leaders, and receive guidance from a circle of six advisors, including Schewel, Durham superintendent Mubenga, former Mayor Bill Bell and state Rep. Marcia Morey.

The board will also be hiring a full-time executive director soon and putting together a list of “very specific measurable targets,” Gonzales-Smith said.

Information on how to contribute can be found at

Durham superintendent apologizes for Monday morning chaos

Durham Public Schools Superintendent Pascal Mubenga apologized Thursday night for holding classes on Monday, when torrential rains and a tornado warning caused chaos on the streets.

“It was a really tough day for our students, our staff, our families and our community members,” Mubenga said during a meeting of the school board. “That’s an experience that I will not let my staff go through another day.”

Mubenga said his team met Tuesday for a post-mortem. Aaron Beaulieu, chief operating officer for Durham Public Schools, explained the decisions school officials had made beginning Sunday afternoon.

He said school maintenance staff checked the district’s facilities and roadways Sunday afternoon for potential hazards. By then, the county had closed its emergency management center and the Red Cross had shut down its shelters.

A steady rain began Sunday night, but when school officials checked the weather between 4 a.m. and 5 a.m., they determined the conditions were manageable.

Then the rain picked up. At 5:13 a.m., the National Weather Service issued a flash flood warning. At 7:32 a.m., the weather service issued the first of two tornado warnings.

“The early morning conditions became more severe than it was being forecast and took most agencies and businesses in the community by surprise,” Beaulieu said.

By that point, the buses were running, and authorities decided it would be safer for them to continue their routes so students could take shelter at schools.

“I take full responsibility for the decision,” Beaulieu said. “I regret that the conditions became such that for a time period we were truly not able to have a safe environment for the operation of schools.”

Mubenga said he would adjust his approach to storm-related school closures and report back to the board with a new plan next month.

‘It turned out we made the wrong decision’

Over the weekend, it seemed like Durham had largely escaped the impact of Hurricane Florence. The city experienced some rain and had scattered power outages, but nothing close to the devastation that occurred elsewhere in the Carolinas.

And then the rains came Sunday night. By Monday morning, the torrential downpour turned rush hour into a chaos of flooded roads and tornado warnings. A school bus got stuck in the mud. Some homes had to be evacuated.

Twitter and school switchboards lit up with complaints from parents who were angry over Durham’s decision to hold classes when several neighboring districts remained closed.

Lamont Lilly, who drove his 11th-grade daughter to Southern High School, was amazed that officials would transport students in such poor weather.

“I know what I saw in our 15 minutes of a ride,” Lilly said. “And I said to myself, ‘I really wouldn’t want a school bus driving through this.’”

Jen Meldrum, treasurer of the parent-teacher association at Forest View Elementary School and a parent to students in the first, fifth and eighth grades, echoed Lilly’s sentiment. “Normally you don’t cancel school for rain, but the fact was that these roads were flooding,” she said. “I don’t think that the buses probably should have been running.”

Meldrum said she tried several routes when driving her younger sons to school, eventually opting to run her car through the water on Erwin Road.

“I heard from one parent who said she had to take three different ways to go,” Meldrum said. “I have a feeling a lot of people did not send their kids in today.”

Durham Public Schools apologized late Monday to parents and staff troubled by the decision to hold classes.

“Although we made the best decision we could with the information we had this morning, we are sorry to our families and staff for the difficulties that came from our decision to open school,” the district said in a statement.

The statement said school buses would be routed around any remaining impassable roads and that all after-school activities and athletic events had been canceled.

Meldrum and Lilly said parents of schoolchildren also received a phone call from the school system at about 9 a.m. that explained that any absences resulting from the weather would be marked as excused, meaning students would not be penalized.

Chip Sudderth, chief communications officer for Durham Public Schools, said officials relied on the best information they had when they made the decision on Sunday.

Between conversations with city/county emergency management on Sunday evening and our own review of weather forecasts and road conditions beginning at 3:30 am, we were confident in our decision,” Sudderth said. “And it turned out we made the wrong decision.”

“I think once buses are running, it’s hard to pull them back and hard to make changes,” said school board member Natalie Beyer, who noted that the decision to open schools was made by Superintendent Pascal Mubenga and his team, not the school board.

“That was kind of the worst-case scenario all the way around,” Beyer said. “I think it was a very rare occurrence to have tornado warnings at the same time that children were at bus stops.”

Sudderth said Durham Public Schools would be convening “a group of major decision-makers” Tuesday to evaluate the information that factored into its decision and what went wrong. “We’re apologizing and we promise to do better,” he said.

When Florence started nearing the Carolina coastline last week, officials and emergency management personnel in Durham braced for an impact similar to that left by Hurricane Fran, which brought 79 mph winds to the Raleigh-Durham area and shut down Durham public schools for six days in September 1996. But Florence meandered to the west and caused more flooding. As it weakened, it seems that Durham officials began to relax.

County Commissioner Heidi Carter said the district began intensive emergency planning on Monday, Sept. 10, and continued at a slightly lower intensity through Sunday night. “Every day, leaders were meeting twice a day looking at all the information they had about the weather,” she said.

“It was just late [Sunday] that they lifted that level of advanced preparedness,” Carter said. “Then people didn’t spend the night in the operations center for the first time last night.”

The rain picked up dramatically in Durham after midnight Sunday, coming down hardest between 5 a.m. and 6 a.m. The rain gauge at Maureen Joy Charter School measured almost 7 inches of rain by noon Monday.

“I have no trouble at all believing that the intensity of the storm this morning caught people off guard,” Carter said, adding that emergency personnel returned to the operations center at 5 a.m. Monday. “Work did gear up quickly, but not in time to warn people that flooding was coming.”

At 5:13 a.m., the National Weather Service issued a flash flood warning. At 7:32 a.m., the weather service issued a tornado warning, which was passed along by the Alert Durham service:


Some of the alerts that Durham residents received Monday morning.

When the flooding came, it made several major roadways impassable. At approximately 9:30 a.m., Orange County and Durham City firefighters were dispatched to Pickett Road, where a school bus got its back wheels stuck in a ditch after trying to turn around.

Durham public schools were not the only entity affected by the downpour. The flash flooding meant slow commutes, and some people had to evacuate their homes.

Interim Durham Fire Chief Chris Iannuzzi said 14 people were rescued from their homes Monday morning in North Durham due to flooding from the Eno River.

Eleven people were evacuated from houses on Rippling Stream Road in the Old Farm neighborhood just south of the riverbank. Three people were rescued in boats due to nearby flooding on Felicia Street, and the fire department also carried three more people trapped on top of a car on Hillandale Drive to dry land in a boat, Iannuzzi said.

By 3:30 p.m., the flooding had receded enough for the evacuees to return home safely, although standing water remained in their backyards. Iannuzzi said the intensity of Monday’s storm was unexpected, but praised his department’s mobilization to take action quickly.

“They train for this stuff, and they don’t get a chance to use it a lot,” said Iannuzzi, who has worked for the Durham Fire Department since 1996. “We don’t even remember a time outside of actually in the Eno River or in Falls Lake where we’ve put the boats in to make a rescue … This was certainly a unique event for us.”

Staff writers Hank Tucker, Ben Leonard and Daniela Flamini contributed to this report.

Update: Durham schools to shut down Thursday and Friday

Durham public schools will shut down Thursday and Friday in anticipation of Hurricane Florence, school officials announced Wednesday.

The decision was made “in the best interest of families and DPS staff and to allow for appropriate preparation for Hurricane Florence,” a press release said.

Previously, school officials had announced that schools would let out three hours early Thursday and remain closed through the weekend. All after-school activities and athletic events will remain canceled Thursday through Sunday.

Public schools to close early on Thursday, remain shut through weekend

Durham Public Schools will close early Thursday and remain shut down through the weekend due to Hurricane Florence, school officials announced Tuesday.

Students will be released three hours early on Thursday. After-school activities have also been canceled Thursday through Sunday, and plans are in the works to open shelters at select Durham schools for residents that need them.

And how likely is it that the closures will extend beyond the weekend? It’s too early to know the strength and impact of the storm, but many Durham residents tracking Florence have noted its similarity to Hurricane Fran, a Category 3 storm that brought 79 mph winds to the Raleigh-Durham area in September 1996.

Durham public schools closed for six days following Fran, according to archived reports from The News & Observer. School officials later adjusted that year’s calendar to add five and a half make-up days in November and January, including a few days during winter break.

Durham officials are encouraging families and staff to prepare emergency kits and monitor the district’s website and social media for further updates and announcements. Durham residents can sign up to receive personal emergency notifications at